Part 4 – Nerds Gone Wild – Wired Markets in Distress



Financial Nerds Gone Wild – Global Markets in Distress

The original plan for this book stopped after the three parts that you’ve just read. These parts are about how markets became machines, and about using more machines to pick stocks and trade them electronically, bringing in an assortment of nifty ideas from finance and computer science along the way.

By the fall of 2008, it was clear that stopping there would have made for a book that seemed quaint. How could any financial author ignore what has happened since then? The problem was that I had spent my entire financial career in the stock markets, and the stock market was a victim, not a cause, of the Great Mess of ’08.* The causes came not from the stock side of Wall Street, but from a mix of abuses, greed, and sheer stupidity from the people who created, repackaged, and sold overly complex derivatives that started with mortgage loans that should never have been made, and were assembled into an over-leveraged financial house of cards that is still collapsing today.

These final chapters are about that collapse. Chapter 12 – Shooting the Moon: Stupid Financial Technology Tricks, is about how wildly complex derivatives traded in opaque markets, and the misuse of mathematical models to value them, contributed to the mess.

This is informative on how responsible use of market technology might have avoided the crisis and can help avoid an even more dreadful sequel in the future. Technology errors of omission and commission have contributed to our present woes. Stock markets are almost perfectly transparent, with full information available to all, and the best electronic clearing and settlement in history. These technologies were omitted in building the skyscraper of cards (“house of cards” seems too mild) out of collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), credit default swaps (CDSs), synthetic collateralized debt obligations (SCDOs), and the rest.

The Hall of Shame for those guilty of incompetent engineering features collapsing bridges, flaming dirigibles, exploding spacecraft, and melting reactors. We can add a new wing for overly complex derivatives, modeled in exquisite detail by myopic nerds with Ph.D.’s who got lost in the ever more complex simulations but ignored the basic principles, and their lavishly paid bosses who ignored the warnings from the best of them so they could be even more lavishly paid.

Chapter 13 – Structural Ideas for the Economic Rescue, expresses the view that as structural flaws in the current recovery plan become increasingly apparent, it seems clear that there is a need for a coherent systems approach to these problems. At first, I felt a great deal of trepidation about delving into this. As a longtime stock guy, I felt I didn’t know what I was talking about in this area. It has become increasingly clear that the people who are in charge don’t know what they are talking about, either. They try to solve problems charging up one hill with $700 billion of our money, drop a couple of hundred billion, then charge back down leaving the same problems in place.

Many aspects of the plans put forth are overly complex, and seem to ignore central aspects of the problem to protect and further enrich the people and institutions that created the mess. This chapter describes two original ideas suggested by my colleagues that address key issues in the economic recovery in a simple, straightforward way. Both have a near circuit designer’s approach, removing “gain” in a system that makes it unstable, and bypassing systemic flaws that impede the desired goals. These ideas are:

  • Fractional home ownership. My Berkeley office-mate John O’Brien is one of the founders of the field of financial engineering. His idea, which expands on a suggestion from Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke, has the potential to address the crisis where it started, in the housing market.
  • New American bank initiative. This is an idea for getting ourselves out of the hole we are in. With my coauthor for this chapter, Sal Khan, I describe a structural solution, free of the inherent flaws and conflicts that have resulted in a tragic waste of time and money in recent months.

Chapter 14 – Nerds Gone Green, discusses how many nerds are finding themselves cast out of Wall Street. Some will find their way back, but many will not. What’s a former Wall Street nerd to do? The answer may lie in market technology that is valuable outside of financial markets. Just as the Internet started out as a way for the Department of Defense to link military computers, there are future uses for market technology that may rival or surpass those involving traditional financial instruments.

Efficient, environmentally sound use of energy is one of the most important. We hear from voices as diverse as Thomas Friedman, T. Boone Pickens, and Ted Turner that energy technology is the next big thing. It is not just about making energy; it is about matching the consumers and the producers of this resource. For oil, the markets are there. For electricity, they are not, at least not in a useful way (unless you were Enron in 1999). Matching consumers, at the individual and business level, and producers, including small alternative suppliers of solar panels, is an allocation and communication problem.

Wired markets have developed to a remarkable level in finance, giving individual buyers and sellers the capabilities to interact with each other and with market makers using direct electronic access that was once found only in large institutions. There is a parallel path in energy markets. Simple real-time spot pricing is not a full solution.

Consumers need to know that cutting back today to help producers produce less pollution or greenhouse gases will not cost them more tomorrow. They effectively need software to manage trade futures, and it needs to be simple and reliable—a considerable technology challenge. Nerds with pink slips may find they go well with green.

>>>>>> READ MORE HERE < <<<<<<

* Jon Stewart has a much better non–politically correct name for what has transpired lately. It begins with “Cluster.” But everyone tells me I can’t put it in the book or use it at conferences. I think you need to watch the Daily Show to pick up on its continuing economic coverage. Stephen Colbert, whose show follows Stewart’s, says the financial markets are like a roller-coaster ride where you vomit money. This brand of fake news has its share of dumb gags, to be sure, but there is more “truthiness” to be found there than in much of what passes for serious broadcast journalism.

Recent guests include Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, John McCain, and Tony Blair. There are frequent appearances by Al Gore, that pesky rascal responsible for all the weird weather lately, who is a huge Daily Show fan. In The Assault on Reason (Penguin Press, 2007) Gore praises Stewart to the sky, and quotes Dan Rather in pointing out that a great deal of mainstream television news is “dumbed down and tarted up … to glue eyeballs to the screen … and sell advertising.” (p. 17)

Wall Street Analytics

Easily find all of the
lowest cost no load
mutual funds and ETFs
Available at major ebook stores:

Amazon -- Kindle/MOBI
index funds list investing books

Apple iBookstore -- iPad/EPUB
index mutual funds investment guide

Barnes & Noble -- Nook/EPUB
no load mutual funds investment guide

Smashwords -- EPUB, MOBI, PDF
low cost mutual funds investment guide

no load index mutual funds
by David Leinweber